Re-drafting SF and CIN

[Seattle Mariners (zach)]

It has been suggested by a few teams that re-drafting SF and CIN might be in the best interest of the league. Some back story so everyone knows, we kicked out an owner a few weeks ago that was running both the SF and CIN teams. He was using the SF team as his good team and funneling everything of value from CIN to SF. This has made SF an incredibly good team and left CIN in shambles with Wil Myers/Rusney Castillo as the only things of value. It's going to be difficult to fill the CIN as it would take several years to make it remotely competitive. I can't imagine someone wanting to pay $50 for that team and without re-drafting I would have to offer the team at a discount. Having both teams redraft from only the players from CIN and SF would balance both teams out and would reduce the effect the colluding owner had on the league.

Please vote on the poll and if you vote no, express why in the comments.

[Seattle Mariners (zach)]

For clarity, I will give the current SF owner the opportunity to switch teams or remain as SF.

[Oakland A's (Scott)]

Its tough since we already have a new owner for SFG, but my vote is to redraft. Those trades between SFG & CIN were pretty bad.

From To Player

Cincinnati Reds San Francisco Giants Walker, Taijuan SP,P - SEA

Cincinnati Reds San Francisco Giants Gonzalez, Carlos OF - COL

Cincinnati Reds San Francisco Giants Refsnyder, Rob (R) 2B - NYY

Cincinnati Reds San Francisco Giants Arroyo, Bronson SP,P - ARI/ATL/LAD

Cincinnati Reds San Francisco Giants Dickerson, Corey OF - COL

San Francisco Giants Cincinnati Reds Stratton, Chris SP,P - SF

San Francisco Giants Cincinnati Reds Ruf, Darin 1B,OF - PHI

San Francisco Giants Cincinnati Reds Escobar, Edwin (R) RP,P - BOS

San Francisco Giants Cincinnati Reds Kolek, Tyler (R) SP,P - MIA

San Francisco Giants Cincinnati Reds Segura, Jean SS - MIL

San Francisco Giants Cincinnati Reds Renfroe, Hunter (R) OF - SD



Cincinnati Reds San Francisco Giants Moncada, Yoan (R) 2B - BOS

Cincinnati Reds San Francisco Giants d'Arnaud, Travis C - NYM

Cincinnati Reds San Francisco Giants Urias, Julio (R) SP,P - LAD

Cincinnati Reds San Francisco Giants Salazar, Danny SP,P - CLE

Cincinnati Reds San Francisco Giants Inciarte, Ender OF - ARI

San Francisco Giants Cincinnati Reds Kang, Jung-ho (R) 3B,SS - PIT

San Francisco Giants Cincinnati Reds Cole, A.J. (R) SP,RP,P - WAS

San Francisco Giants Cincinnati Reds Jackson, Luke (R) SP,RP,P - TEX

San Francisco Giants Cincinnati Reds 2016 Draft Pick, Round 3 (Houston Astros)

San Francisco Giants Cincinnati Reds Arroyo, Christian (R) SS - SF

San Francisco Giants Cincinnati Reds Myers, Wil 1B,OF - SD



Cincinnati Reds San Francisco Giants Graveman, Kendall (R) SP,RP,P - OAK

Cincinnati Reds San Francisco Giants Moran, Colin (R) 3B - HOU

Cincinnati Reds San Francisco Giants Schwarber, Kyle (R) C,OF - CHC

Cincinnati Reds San Francisco Giants Stephenson, Robert (R) SP,P - CIN

San Francisco Giants Cincinnati Reds Butler, Eddie (R) SP,P - COL

San Francisco Giants Cincinnati Reds Chavis, Michael SS - BOS

San Francisco Giants Cincinnati Reds Eflin, Zach SP,P - PHI

San Francisco Giants Cincinnati Reds Ervin, Phillip (R) OF - CIN

San Francisco Giants Cincinnati Reds Travis, Sam 1B - BOS

[blake]

So when these teams get redrafted, which is pretty much inevitable, I can't really switch teams now considering the other teams I were considering are claimed now. Since I don't know a lot about the league, will I get back any of my draft picks that are long gone (which I'm sure he used in other trades) and any cap space?

This just sucks all around. I would have taken my second/third choices to stay out of this black hole.

[Blake - SF Owner]

Also, how did these trades go through? I haven't read through the constitution yet, but if these were so bad, why were they permitted?

Anyone know of any other ridiculous trades that guy made. Since I currently don't have a draft pick this year, I'm curious as to what he spent it on and if I'm going to lose that guy.

(not sure why I can't sign in to the boards, but it won't let me)